Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jerry Halberstadt's avatar

Wendy, this is painful to read, but necessary to comprehend. Reading your column yesterday about the signs of crematoria, I took seriously because I have come to trust that you do your homework before writing. Today's article has shaken me.

Decades ago, I read Shirer's "Rise and Fall of the Third Reich," and concluded that the Holocaust could happen in America. Indeed, our country has been built on murdering Native Americans, enslaving Black people, segregation; and now the systematic destruction of democratic institutions.

The Nazi regime copied American eugenics and other evil from us; now, "what goes around, comes around." It has come home to roost.

As a Jew, I am aware that my people are in as much danger as the immigrants who are being detained, tortured, and expelled.

No one is safe unless we are all safe.

What are we going to do to defend our safety?

Pam Pancake's avatar

I read your article, Wendy, then sent this to my former university student, now friend, who lives with family in Surprise, AZ. This friend works for Americans Defending Freedom, an entity that supports lawyers working on Republican/Conservative-tied cases and causes:

Hi! Just doing some reading on the new detention camps going up in the U.S. It’s quite a lucrative business. Lots of taxpayer dollars going into funding the system, including your hard-earned dollars, and my retired dollars.

Immigrant detainee deaths in Trump’s confinement warehouses: one person every six days. None of those people needed to die.

When Surprise gets its 1,500 detainees, some will be deported, some will die preventable deaths in Surprise, and new detainees will come in to fill the beds. I wonder what they do with the bodies, one every six days. That’s quite a lot of people. Do they bury them in Surprise, or cart them off by train somewhere else?

Diseases like measles, mumps, polio, Covid, and a host of others will spread, and, not only to the detainees. Guards, cafeteria workers, staff will get sick, as well, and bring it home to their mates and children, and it will spread through your community and into your schools, and, ultimately, into your children. Trump’s war on vaccines will make it a much worse problem. ‘Surprise’ takes on new meaning.

You’ll have new people in town, as ICE officers burn out quickly, protesters will chant outside, lawyers and social workers will come, families will come…and your hotels will be filled with ICE-related visitors.

What a sad story for a town with a wonderful name. Tourism, composed of nice singles, couples and families, won’t be able to vacation there. Your new neighbors will be prison-related.

I’m not trying to scare you, but I want you to go into it with eyes wide open. These people, the detainees, mostly came to the U.S. for a better life. I know some Hispanics who are here illegally, and they are good people, very hard workers trying to make it here, to have a better life here. They want more for their children, just as we did and do.

I hope you and your church will be compassionate to the inmates and the people who come in to represent them. The Pope kisses the feet of the homeless, to let them know they are equals in the eyes of Jesus. Christ kissed the feet of prostitutes, poor working women who resorted to the one possession they had, to let them know that they were loved, by him and God. I hope your church can find ways to help and show human compassion to these ‘illegals’, and to any children incarcerated there.

Did you know that more violence in the U.S. is done by white male citizens? Not Black men or Black teens. Not Hispanics or Muslims. Not women of any color. White men who have a twisted sense of privilege.

This system and its processes are just wrong. Is this who we, U.S. citizens, want to be? Cruel people?

20 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?